Amazon Exit Strategy for Supplement Brands | Reduce Dependency 70% to 50% in 90 Days | Exit Strategy Ads

Amazon Exit Strategy for Supplement Brands: Reduce Marketplace Dependency from 70-85% to Under 50% in 90 Days

Build a profitable direct-to-consumer channel with Google Ads while keeping (and growing) your Amazon sales. Month-to-month service. 3:1 ROAS guarantee in 90 days or we work for free. You own everything we build.

Book Your Free Amazon Dependency Audit See Pricing & Programs

The Triple Guarantee: You're Protected

We're confident in the Independence System. That's why we back it with three guarantees that remove your risk.

Quick Answer:

Exit Strategy Ads guarantees 3:1 ROAS within 90 days, complete infrastructure delivery (landing pages + email systems + traffic), and month-to-month flexibility with no long-term contracts. If we don't deliver results, you get free management in Months 4-5.

#1

Performance Guarantee

We guarantee minimum 3:1 ROAS on your DTC revenue within 90 days. If we don't hit this target, we waive your monthly management fee for Months 4 and 5 while continuing to optimize your campaigns. If we follow our full playbook and still don't get you to 3:1 ROAS, we'll help you find the right next partner and provide a complete handoff of assets and documentation to make the transition seamless. We're that confident in our system.

#2

Infrastructure Guarantee

Complete DTC infrastructure delivered within 90 days: landing pages, email sequences, tracking systems, and qualified traffic. If we don't deliver, we work free in Months 4-5 until we do.

#3

Freedom Guarantee

Both programs are month-to-month with 30 days' written notice—no long-term contracts.

Monthly Program: No termination fees. You keep all assets we build.

Partnership Program: If you cancel before Month 12, you repay the unearned discount (the difference between Partnership and Monthly rates)—we'll refund any unused prepaid management fees. After Month 12, there's no recapture.

In every case, you keep all deliverables (landing pages, emails, campaign docs, customer data). You own everything we build.

Why Amazon Dependency is Dangerous for Supplement Brands

Most supplement brands are 70-85% dependent on Amazon. One policy change, one account suspension, one fee increase—and revenue collapses overnight.

Quick Answer:

Amazon dependency means 70-85% of your revenue comes from a single platform you don't control. Supplement brands face account suspensions (35% in 2024), pay $65k-$75k monthly in fees at $200k revenue, get zero customer data, and sell businesses at 2-3x EBITDA instead of 3.5-5x for diversified brands.

35%

Seller Suspensions in 2024

Amazon suspended 35% of sellers in 2024. Policy changes happen without notice. Supplement brands face stricter enforcement than any other category. Your business can disappear overnight.

$65k-$75k

Monthly Amazon Fees

A supplement brand doing $200k/month on Amazon pays $65,000-$75,000 in fees: 15% referral fees, 10% FBA fees, $15k-$25k in advertising. You're paying Amazon to rent their platform.

2-3x

Lower Business Valuation

Amazon-dependent businesses sell at 2-3x EBITDA. Diversified businesses with owned customer data sell at 3.5-5x EBITDA. Platform dependency costs you $450k-$600k in exit value on a $300k EBITDA business.

Why 2025 is the Critical Year to Reduce Amazon Dependency

Recent policy changes and industry trends are forcing supplement brands to build independence now or risk catastrophic business disruption.

Quick Answer:

Amazon announced stricter supplement testing requirements in Q4 2024, fee increases effective January 2025, and expanded restricted ingredient lists. Brands building DTC channels now gain 12-18 months of competitive advantage before competitors react to the crisis.

Amazon Policy Changes in 2024-2025 That Impact Supplement Brands

Amazon implemented the most aggressive supplement policy changes in five years. November 2024 brought mandatory third-party testing for all immune, sleep, and cognitive health supplements through only three approved organizations. Testing costs $8,000-$12,000 per SKU. Non-compliant listings were deactivated immediately—no warning, no grace period.

January 2025 fee increases added 2.5% to referral fees (now 17.5% for supplements over $20), increased FBA storage fees by 15%, and added new "low-inventory-level fees" penalizing brands with less than 28 days of stock. Combined impact: 8-12% margin compression for most supplement sellers.

The restricted ingredient list expanded to include common adaptogens and nootropics that were previously allowed. NAC (N-acetyl cysteine) was banned entirely in November 2024. DMHA and DMAE face pending restriction. Ashwagandha and rhodiola now require enhanced documentation. Brands discovered violations face immediate suppression.

How Supplement Brands Can Reduce Amazon Dependency: The Competitive Timing Advantage

Most supplement brands are paralyzed by these changes—focused on compliance, absorbing fee increases, and hoping Amazon doesn't target them next. Smart brands are using this crisis moment to build independence while competitors remain reactive. Building a DTC channel now gives you 12-18 months of competitive advantage before other sellers realize they need diversification.

The brands that will dominate 2026-2027 are the ones building owned customer acquisition channels in 2025. When the next round of restrictions hits, you'll have a business that survives regardless of Amazon's decisions.

The Independence System: Own Your Channel, Amplify Amazon

We don't help brands leave Amazon. We help them stop being dependent on Amazon. Build a self-sustaining direct-to-consumer channel that protects your business and increases valuation.

Quick Answer:

The Independence System builds complete DTC infrastructure (Google Ads campaigns, landing pages, email automation, retargeting audiences) that generates 3:1+ ROAS while typically increasing Amazon sales 10-20% due to brand awareness. You reduce dependency while growing total revenue.

What Is the Exit Strategy Ads Independence System?

The Independence System is a complete direct-to-consumer infrastructure that reduces marketplace dependency while growing total revenue. It includes five critical components that work together to create a sustainable, owned acquisition channel.

  • Revenue Engine: Profitable Google Ads campaigns (Search, Shopping, Performance Max) optimized for 3:1+ ROAS that generate consistent customer acquisition independent of Amazon.
  • Customer Ownership: Email lists (5,000-20,000+ subscribers over 12 months), first-party customer data, purchase history, and behavior tracking that Amazon never shares with sellers.
  • Conversion Infrastructure: 5-10 high-converting landing pages, 10-20+ email automation sequences, cart abandonment recovery, and post-purchase nurture flows optimized for supplement buyers.
  • Retargeting Assets: 5,000-50,000+ person retargeting audiences, pixel tracking across touchpoints, and behavior-based segmentation that creates recurring visibility.
  • Systems Documentation: Complete campaign SOPs, tracking dashboards, and optimization playbooks you own forever—even if you stop working with us.

What Actually Happens to Your Amazon Sales When You Build a DTC Channel?

Most brands see Amazon revenue increase by 10-20% while building their DTC channel. Why? Brand awareness. Your Google Ads, email campaigns, and retargeting create massive visibility. People see your brand multiple times, Google your name, find your Amazon listing, and buy there because they trust Amazon checkout. You win either way.

Industry example: A cognitive health supplement brand started at $120k/month Amazon (83% dependent) and $24k other channels. Nine months later: $140k/month Amazon (54% dependent) and $120k/month DTC revenue. Amazon grew 17% while dependency dropped 29 percentage points. Total business revenue increased from $144k to $260k monthly.

Real-World Case Study: From 85% Amazon Dependent to 47% in 9 Months

Month-by-month progression showing exactly how the Independence System reduces dependency while growing total revenue.

Women's Health Supplement Brand Transformation

Starting Position: $250,000/month Amazon revenue (85% of total business), $44,000/month from other channels (website, Amazon international, wholesale). Total monthly revenue: $294,000. Zero email subscribers. No DTC acquisition strategy.

Goal: Reduce Amazon dependency to under 50% within 12 months while maintaining or growing Amazon revenue. Build owned email list. Create sustainable DTC acquisition channel.

Month 1-2: Foundation & Launch

Completed onboarding, FDA/FTC compliance review, implemented server-side tracking, created 10 landing page wireframes, integrated Klaviyo email platform. Launched Google Ads campaigns (Search + Shopping + Performance Max) with $10,000 ad spend Month 1, $12,000 Month 2.

  • Month 1 DTC Revenue: $18,000 (2.8:1 ROAS after learning phase)
  • Month 2 DTC Revenue: $28,000 (3.1:1 ROAS as campaigns optimized)
  • Email subscribers captured: 340 (Month 1), 580 (Month 2)
  • Amazon revenue: $255,000 Month 1, $262,000 Month 2 (grew 4.8% from brand awareness effect)
  • Amazon dependency: 82% (Month 2)

Month 3-6: Optimization & Scaling

A/B tested ad creative, refined audiences based on conversion data, launched retargeting campaigns (sufficient pixel data accumulated), deployed all 10 landing pages, activated email automation sequences. Increased ad spend to $15,000/month.

  • Month 6 DTC Revenue: $52,000 (4.1:1 ROAS on mature campaigns)
  • Email subscribers: 3,200 total (averaging 600 new/month)
  • Amazon revenue: $278,000 (11% growth from start, driven by brand visibility)
  • Total monthly revenue: $330,000 (12% growth from start)
  • Amazon dependency: 64%

Month 7-9: Mature Performance

Campaigns fully optimized, email automation generating 15% of DTC revenue from existing list, retargeting producing 5:1+ ROAS, continued scaling ad spend to $18,000/month by Month 9.

  • Month 9 DTC Revenue: $78,000 (4.7:1 ROAS)
  • Email subscribers: 5,800 total
  • Amazon revenue: $292,000 (17% growth from start)
  • Total monthly revenue: $370,000 (26% growth from start)
  • Amazon dependency: 47%

Key Outcomes

Business Transformation: Reduced Amazon dependency from 85% to 47% in 9 months. Amazon revenue grew 17% during same period. Total business revenue increased 26%. Email list grew from zero to 5,800+ owned contacts. Created sustainable DTC acquisition channel producing $78,000+ monthly at 4.7:1 ROAS.

Valuation Impact: Business now sells at 4-4.5x EBITDA (diversified, owned customers) instead of 2.5-3x EBITDA (Amazon dependent). On $900,000 annual EBITDA, that's $3.6M-$4.05M exit value versus $2.25M-$2.7M. Independence System added $1.35M-$1.35M to business value.

Two Ways to Work With Us: Monthly vs Partnership

Both programs include the complete Independence System, Triple Guarantee, and month-to-month flexibility. Choose based on your commitment level and budget preferences.

Quick Answer:

Monthly Program: $7,500 setup + $5,500/month + 12% of ad spend. Partnership Program: $0 setup + $4,000/month + 9% of ad spend. Partnership saves $29,040 over 12 months compared to Monthly. Both require minimum $8,000/month Google Ads spend.

Monthly Program

$7,500
One-time setup + $5,500/month

Plus 12% of Google Ads spend (minimum $8,000/month ad spend required)

  • 5 FDA-compliant landing pages
  • 10 email automation sequences
  • Professional support (48-hour response)
  • Monthly strategy calls
  • Complete Google Ads management
  • Triple Guarantee included
  • Month-to-month, cancel anytime
  • Zero termination fees

Best for: Brands wanting proof before deeper commitment, need maximum flexibility, or want to test the system first.

Choose Monthly Program
Most Popular

Partnership Program

$0
Setup waived + $4,000/month

Plus 9% of Google Ads spend (minimum $8,000/month ad spend required)

  • 10 FDA-compliant landing pages (delivered Month 2)
  • 20+ email automation sequences
  • VIP support (24-hour priority response)
  • Quarterly deep-dive sessions + monthly calls
  • Complete Google Ads management
  • Triple Guarantee included
  • Month-to-month after Month 12
  • Save $29,040 over 12 months vs Monthly

Best for: Brands ready to commit to building real DTC channel, want maximum value, and appreciate VIP support. 70% of brands choose Partnership.

Choose Partnership Program
Feature
Monthly
Partnership
Setup Fee
$7,500
$0 (save $7,500)
Monthly Management
$5,500
$4,000 (save $1,500/mo)
Ad Spend Fee
12%
9% (save 3%)
Landing Pages
5
10 (delivered Month 2)
Email Sequences
10
20+
Year 1 Total Cost*
$205,660
$176,620 (save $29,040)

*Assumes $120k total Google Ads spend over 12 months ($10k/month average)

How We Build Your Independence System in 90 Days

Clear roadmap. Proven process. Guaranteed results.

1

Weeks 1-2: Foundation

Onboarding, FDA/FTC compliance review, tracking implementation (Google Ads, GA4, server-side), landing page wireframes, email platform integration. Your campaigns are architected for compliance and performance.

2

Weeks 3-4: Launch

Google Ads campaigns go live (Search, Shopping, Performance Max), landing pages deployed, email capture flows activated, retargeting pixels firing. You're now driving DTC traffic and building your Independence System.

3

Days 30-60: Optimize

Daily monitoring and bid adjustments, A/B testing ad creative, audience refinement based on performance data, budget reallocation to winning campaigns. Weekly KPI emails keep you informed.

4

Days 60-90: Scale

Expansion to proven winners, additional campaign types launched, retargeting campaigns activated (audience data built), landing page optimization based on conversion data. Formal 90-day performance report delivered.

Expected Results: What Supplement Brands Typically Achieve

Based on supplement brands investing $8,000-$15,000/month in Google Ads through the Independence System.

3-6 mo
Time to 50% Dependency

Most brands reduce Amazon dependency from 70-85% to under 50% within 6-12 months while maintaining or growing Amazon revenue through brand awareness effects.

3.8:1
Average ROAS Month 6+

Typical performance on mature campaigns after algorithms optimize. Month 1-2 averages 2.5-3:1 during learning phase. Months 3-6 climb to 3.5-4.5:1 as optimization improves.

$35k-$50k
Monthly DTC Revenue by Month 6

At $10k-$15k/month ad spend with 3:1-4:1 ROAS. Builds email list of 8,000-12,000 subscribers. Creates recurring revenue stream independent of Amazon platform risk.

Amazon-Dependent vs. Independence System Business

Two businesses. Same revenue. Dramatically different outcomes.

Metric
Amazon-Dependent
Independence System
Amazon Dependency
85% of revenue
45% of revenue
Customer Data Owned
Zero emails, zero data
15,000+ emails, complete data
Suspension Risk
Business ends if suspended
DTC continues uninterrupted
Business Valuation
2-3x EBITDA
3.5-5x EBITDA
Exit Value ($300k EBITDA)
$600k-$900k
$1.05M-$1.5M

Why We Only Work With Supplement Brands

Extreme specialization means we understand your specific challenges better than any generalist agency.

Supplement-Only Expertise Creates Better Results

Exit Strategy Ads works exclusively with natural supplement brands doing $50,000-$500,000 per month on Amazon. We only do one thing: build Independence Systems through Google Ads and DTC infrastructure. This extreme specialization means better, faster results.

Most marketing agencies serve every industry—e-commerce, B2B, local services, SaaS. They learn on your dime. Generalist agencies don't understand FDA/FTC compliance requirements for supplement advertising, don't know which Google Ads targeting works specifically for supplement buyers, lack proven landing page templates optimized for supplement conversion rates, and have never built Amazon Attribution integration for tracking external traffic.

  • FDA/FTC Compliance Expertise: We understand structure/function claims vs disease claims, required disclaimers, restricted ingredient categories, and supplement-specific advertising regulations across Google, Meta, and all channels.
  • Supplement Buyer Psychology: We know how health-conscious consumers research supplements, what objections they have about buying from new brands, which proof elements convert skeptics, and how to position premium pricing.
  • Amazon Seller Challenges: We understand marketplace dependency risks, Amazon Attribution integration, brand referral bonuses, and how to use external traffic to improve Amazon organic rankings.
  • Category-Specific Strategies: Different approaches for sports nutrition vs cognitive health vs women's health vs immune support. We've documented what works for each supplement category.
  • Seasonal Planning: Immune support surges in winter, weight management peaks in January, sleep aids perform consistently year-round. We plan campaigns around supplement category seasonality.

We've never had a campaign suspended for compliance violations. We've documented the exact Independence System process that works for supplement brands. We speak your language and understand your business model because it's the only business model we serve.

Is the Independence System Right for Your Supplement Brand?

  • Amazon revenue: $50k-$500k per month
  • Current Amazon dependency: 70-100% of total revenue
  • Ready to invest: $8,000/month minimum in Google Ads (ongoing requirement)
  • Has or building: Direct-to-consumer Shopify store
  • Concerns about: Policy changes, account suspensions, margin erosion, lack of customer ownership
  • Goal: Business stability, customer ownership, reduced platform risk, increased valuation
  • Compliance: No active FDA warnings or serious regulatory issues
  • Timeline: Ready to start building independence within 30 days

Frequently Asked Questions

Direct answers about Amazon dependency, DTC strategy, and working with Exit Strategy Ads.

Book Your Free Amazon Dependency Audit

We'll analyze your Amazon revenue, calculate your exact dependency percentage, project your DTC revenue potential at different ad spend levels, and show you the exact Independence System roadmap for your brand—even if you don't work with us.

The supplement brands winning long-term aren't going all-in on Amazon. They're building defensible, diversified businesses with owned customer data and protection against platform risk.

Claim Your Free Audit Now

We accept a maximum of 15 new clients per quarter to deliver on our 90-day performance guarantees. If you'd like to be considered for the current quarter, book your call today.